I don't usually "rant" on here but today..oh why not?
Let's talk about Public Nursing. (Yes, I said nursing. The term "breastfeeding" is one of my peeves.) There's so much controversy over such a non-controversial topic that it almost isn't worth my time to type this. Yet, I will because it needs to be said.. again.
There is nothing wrong with nursing in public. At the risk of ticking off some readers, I'll go as far as to say that I'd be more ashamed to have my child seen in public with a bottle. It's true. If I were seen loading my child with plastics, hormones and chemicals, I'd just want to crawl in a hole and hide. To ask a woman to leave the room, cover herself or ..and this one is just disgusting.. go in the bathroom to nurse, does nothing more than show one's stupidity and disrespect for the wonderful art of nursing that God himself (substitute the word GOD with NATURE if you don't believe in God) gave to mothers and their babies.
Covering Up: I'll concede the tiniest bit on this. If you as the mother aren't comfortable--then sure.. go ahead.. use a blanket as long as it doesn't irritate baby. However, I will not. Why? Because it defeats a main purpose of nursing: eye to eye contact. That special time when baby just lies there adoring mom and, of course, mom adoring baby. There is a reason nature allows them to see only a certain distance which happens to be the distance from breast to mom's eyes. It's a natural way of bonding them together. Besides, most babies won't tolerate the cover-up. They will pull the blanket off as most nursing moms are well-aware. They're not comfortable having things over their heads (a survival instinct) and want to see mom's face and share that tender moment.
"I don't want to see the mom's boob!" Are you kidding me??? Have you actually ever seen a child nurse? You can't see anything! They're head covers the breast. In order for you to see the breast, the child would need a see-thru head. Now I'll venture to say that if the child's head is see-thru, then you're really not going to be thinking so much about mom's breast as you are about the fact that the head of the child is transparent. So let's get over it.
Why should a baby or child feel embarrassed and ashamed for eating? Does this even make sense? The baby's natural instinct is to be in mom's arms, to be at mom's breast, skin-to-skin. All mammal's do it. Do you tell your dog or cat to go hide? Do we freak when we see Shamu nurse a baby? No. But a human do what a human is designed to do??!!! Uh-oh! No! We can't have that!
In 1900, it was "indiscreet" for a woman's ankle to show but she could sit on the front row at the theatre nursing her child with no questions asked. Now we have girls walking around in hip-huggers and belly shirts; thongs, sex on tv, porn..but we freak out when a woman nurses a child? What is WRONG with this?!
The next time you decide you want to make a nursing mom feel sinful.. think about what things you do, watch or listen to as entertainment; what you wear to the beach (or stare at on the beach) and then talk to me about it. I'm not making a judgement regarding those things; just a point.
Hey Primal!
ReplyDeleteThanks for coming to Drivin' Barefoot and chiming in on my satire on this topic. Even more glad that you saw the humor in it enough to joke back... even though it is obviously an important topic.
The only thing I say to it though is, really, why is covering up too much to ask? Yes, the eye to eye contact is part of it, but does it have to happen with every meal?
Also, why is the mother the only one whose comfort is important? If she chose to expose, why is it everyone else's responsibility to respect her "privacy"? If they feel uncomfortable, that is apparently their problem... well, if them staring, pointing or kids giggling around her make her uncomfortable... in fairness... is her problem.
Yes, nursing should be encouraged, but it can be done discreetly.
I have no problem with "discreet". In fact, as I mentioned in the article.. by nature, nursing is discreet: the baby's head covers everything. I have nursed probably thousands of times in public and no one even KNEW what I was doing unless they've been around nursing moms (maybe family members and such?) before. I've had people come up to admire and coo at the baby only to back up and say "Oh! I didn't realize she was feeding!" No blanket needed thanks.
ReplyDeleteThe article in the paper plainly stated that no one could see her breast. So why the need for the blanket? Why the need for the airline to violate the law/her right to nurse?
As for other's comfort. Well, I'm terribly sorry if grown people are uncomfortable with a child eating. I don't get it. Never will get it. No one is queasy at the site of a bottle and yet that's reprehensible in my opinion. Yet--I never have said "excuse me ma'am.. I'm offended. Please cover your child." ONLY in the western world are we offended. Everywhere else it's as natural and common as seeing a foot or arm. We've sexualized the breast to a ridiculous, unnatural point, far beyond it's natural sexuality.
Nursing is common and natural. ONLY in the western world do we find these skewed attitudes. 80% of the world "breastfeeds" and it's been done for thousands of years. We have formula for 150 years and suddenly nursing is indecent. I don't get it. I truly don't.
Parated2k: Ya know I luvs ya.. but we're gonna have to call this one a stand-still LOL
If kids point and giggle, it's just another proof of how this country is messed up. Even our KIDS think nursing a baby is sexual or dirty or something to giggle at?? Geeesh! That's not really the mother's problem at all.. it's THEIR PARENTS' problem that their kids are so messed up.
ReplyDeleteThe same people who complain about public nursing are the same people who think sex is entertainment and thongs are normal beachwear. The ones who have the least morals are the ones who complain the loudest. How ironic.
RIGHT ON! You know where I stand on this suffice to say. This issue brings out the PRIMAL in me...LOL....At this rate I will end up creating t-shirts and buttons and organizing a march on Washington D.C...Everytime I think about it my blood boils....we've got nude beaches, topless bars aplenty and "Jugs" Magazine but let a woman come out and feed her baby at her breast and she's Public Enemy #1. It's ridiculous...Yeah you're right, if more babies have formula than breastmilk they will have weaker immune systems and be at the doctor's office more often....If you follow that thought to it's obvious conclusion then....And sure I'll cover up the ta-ta's while nursing if I stop seeing the cracks of people's backsides due to thongs and low-riding jeans, and there is an end to topless sun-bathing...Somehow I don't see it...My freedom ends where the next person's nose begins I guess...
ReplyDeleteOk, what I'm getting from these replies is, "Western Culture is just plain wrong about everything".
ReplyDeleteInteresting.
"by nature, nursing is discreet: the baby's head covers everything."
I just had to laugh at this one. Do you really think that all nipples are no bigger than a baby's mouth? That brings a whole new meaning to the joke, "anything more than a mouthful is a waste" ;~D
"Parated2k: Ya know I luvs ya.. but we're gonna have to call this one a stand-still LOL"
Yup, I luvs ya too, and ain't it great that we can disagree about such weighty issues and still get along. ;~D
re:
ReplyDeleteI just had to laugh at this one. Do you really think that all nipples are no bigger than a baby's mouth?
But the baby's HEAD will cover it. I've yet to see a nipple bigger than a child's head LOL ;-)
Unfortunately, as you have stated, western society has got some things really screwed up.
ReplyDeleteI have never understood why it is not acceptable to show a life giving exchange openly on Television, yet we can show somebody with their body destroyed because of some violent act.
Odd...very odd...
I just had to laugh at this one. Do you really think that all nipples are no bigger than a baby's mouth? That brings a whole new meaning to the joke, "anything more than a mouthful is a waste" ;~D
ReplyDeleteUm, you do realize the only part that is the "nipple" is entirely taken into the child's mouth when nursing. You are referring to the areola (sp) and that is NOT the nipple. Not to mention, the fact is, it's still covered by the child's head.
My brother-in-law is a major breastophobe. It made for some tense family gatherings, as his loud criticism just didn't seem worth it. His sisters and mother all claim to have wanted to nurse, but were "unable". The brother's wife, however, chose not to. Personally, I think he had a lot to do with that decision.
ReplyDeleteThe bottom line is twofold- one, my husband tried to educate his older brother and always stood up for us. Second, it never deterred us from feeding our babies as we saw fit.
We have NO regrets.
BTW, we even had a friend who berated me for being TOO discreet when nursing on the deck at a dinner party. She felt I was implying it was obscene to nurse at the dinner table. I just wanted some peaceful time! I guess you just do what you think is best and ignore the radicals on both sides.
I am so glad I found your blog. This nursing in public thing makes me crazy to. At church all the mother's that nurse use blankets when they nurse, I think it's silly, But owell. I get disgusted when I see babies in carseats at the store with bottles shoved in their mouths.
ReplyDelete